A lesson in first draft writing
21 Thursday Aug 2014
Written by Charles Harris in Psychology, Technique
Why do we always have to keep learning the same lessons? Wouldn’t it be nice occasionally for something to stick? I forgot one of the fundamentals of first draft writing and it was painful relearning it. The problem is that you always think you know better. I know – I know only too well – that when you write a first draft, the worst thing you can do is try to get it right. I learnt it myself the hard way, a long time ago, and I teach it all the time.
First drafts are supposed to be a mess
First drafts are supposed to be a mess. If you try to get it right, you find yourself editing, and that kills it stone dead. But then you start to believe you can outsmart the system. Every time I sit down to write a new first draft I think, this time it will be good from the start. This time I’ve learned all the mistakes that can be made, and I’m going to avoid them. After all, I’m a prize-winning writer-director, and I’ve got books coming out: I must know something. And I remember the improvements I had to make last time, all the redrafts, all that I learned. And I say, maybe this time. Maybe this time, I can avoid the mess. The stumbling opening. The confused middle. The limp end. Or at least some of them.
The hubris trap
Earlier this week, the writing had become painful. I struggled to get the words out. Nothing was working. It was the first draft from hell. Then I realised what I’d done. I’d started trying to make the first draft good from the beginning. I’d forgotten the most important rule of them all – don’t get it right, get it written! I’d fallen into the trap of hubris – believing that somehow I was now “better than that”. That I could avoid the mistakes. And you know, the thing is you can’t avoid the mistakes. In fact, you must make the mistakes to find the correct path.
No better “me”
I somehow believed I could escape myself, and be an imaginary “better” writer. But what comes out of the mess of the first draft is me. Like it or not. I can’t escape me. All I can do is put it all down, and polish it up later, so that at least it’s a polished me. That’s all I’ve got. Maybe I’ll remember that lesson for next time.
7 Comments
Mark said:
August 29, 2014 at 10:41 am
Im on my first draft and this really really helped me. Thank You.
Anonymous said:
August 29, 2014 at 10:47 am
Thank you Mr Harris, Im struggling with a first draft and now I know why!
bobeaumont said:
August 29, 2014 at 10:47 am
I have a friend that is wanting to make a go at writing and I think this would help him. I’m sure he’ll end up subscribing.
Susan Duva said:
August 29, 2014 at 10:48 am
Yes this is great advise. Just get started write something, anything, it’s a starting point. You will go back and improve it again and again until it is right.
Charles Harris said:
September 1, 2014 at 9:02 pm
Thank you, Mark, Bob and Susan. It’s strange isn’t it. You’d think it would become easier with experience, but in fact – and many writers say the same thing – it actually gets harder.
Perhaps that’s in part because we expect more of ourselves each time. And we forget that each time we write, it’s a new start. Beginners’ mind – easy to say, not so easy to do.
Wayne Harris said:
September 10, 2014 at 12:14 pm
Charles, what good advice. I’m just writing now and it reinforces my current approach which can do easily slip into editing because I looked back at what I have written.
Charles Harris said:
September 19, 2014 at 1:26 pm
Hi Wayne,
I’m really pleased that it works for you. You’re absolutely right, and the trap is always there. So simple, yet….
C